← All posts

Why the app tells you a time you're free, not a percentage done

A progress bar can tell you how much is behind you and nothing at all about whether the rest of it fits.

The bar says 60%. It's twenty to twelve on a Tuesday, six things ticked off ten, and the question actually in your head has nothing to do with six or ten. It's whether you're getting out of this by six, and whether the thing you promised for Thursday is already quietly impossible.

A percentage done can't answer either one. It measures what's behind you. It knows nothing about the four tasks left, how long any of them really takes, how much of the afternoon your meetings already own, or how you work at three o'clock. You can be ninety percent through a list at four and still be at the desk at nine, because the one that's left is the three-hour one you've been walking past since Monday. The bar climbs at the same friendly rate either way, which is how a day can feel fine at lunch and wrong by six.

So Do › Today opens with something else. "You're free at", and then a time. 3:33pm, with a small chip beside it reading 27m early.

That's a claim, and a claim that can be caught out. Six o'clock arrives and either you were free at 3:33 or you weren't. A progress bar never has to stand behind anything.

Where 3:33 comes from

Planning a day is two sums, and most task management only does the first: what you have to do, how important it is, how soon it's due. The second sum is the sheet of paper. Every checklist ever written has been written on an infinite one, which is why lists grow and why they never end. The size of the sheet is the number of hours you actually have, and that's a real number, measurable, and usually smaller than you'd like.

So the app measures it. Your work window starts from your schedule and widens with what you actually do on that weekday, because your Tuesday and your Friday aren't the same shape. Meetings come out of it, and a meeting sitting on two calendars is counted once instead of twice. A task you've set for a time is held there, like a meeting. What's left is the room, and every task goes into that room at the pace you really work.

Then the minutes. Each task's estimate comes from measured history: your own past times first, then people who've timed the same work, then a category midpoint when nobody has. Whichever one it used shows on the task, so you can see whether the app is going on your record or somebody else's. Nothing asks you to guess. Guessing is the step that was breaking the arithmetic.

Place all of it against the hours and you get a time of day. It moves when the day moves.

The half nobody plans against

Call it the solution for time blindness. The everyday kind is the one almost everybody has: a sense of how long things take that isn't attached to a clock. The list told you what you had to do and when it was due. Nothing told you what you could do.

A time of day is attached to a clock, so you can argue with it. If the app says 3:33 and you know the call at two always runs long, you've found the disagreement in the morning instead of at six, when the only thing left to do about it is feel bad. Sixty percent gives you nothing to push back on.

What to start gets easier too. The card at the top says Why this one in a sentence, and Lock in starts the clock on it, which is also how the estimate for that kind of work gets sharper for next time.

Thursday shows up early, as well. This week lays out each day in task time, the number of things against the hours those things need, labelled Full, Light, Room left or Over. An over-committed Thursday is visible on Tuesday, while moving something is still cheap.

And then the day ends

Once a work day's hours are done, Do shows you the end of the day. Keep going is there if you want to open a free moment and use it, and some evenings you will. The default is that the day is finished, because we cap your day on purpose and a list is supposed to end.

That's what a percentage can't hand you. A bar at 100% is the same information as the empty list already in front of you. "You're free at 3:33pm" was a promise made at nine in the morning, and at 3:33 it either held or it didn't, and when it holds the rest of the evening is genuinely yours, without the low hum of having missed something.

I Heart Checklists is the task manager that does the second sum: estimates built from what your work actually took, placed against the hours you actually have, with the minute you'll be free sitting at the top of Today. The trial is free if you want to find out what your own Tuesday is really sized at.

Sixty percent done is a sentence about this morning. 3:33 is a sentence about tonight.

Your day has a size. Your list should know it.

I Heart Checklists plans around the hours you actually have, then tells you when you're finished. $2.99/mo, 14 days free.

Start free trial